Detecting Aware and Unaware Mind Wandering During Lecture Viewing: A Multimodal Machine Learning Approach Using Eye Tracking, Facial Videos and Physiological Data
Learners often experience aware and unaware mind wandering during educational tasks, both negatively impacting learning outcomes. Differentiating these types of task-unrelated thoughts is crucial, as they stem from different cognitive processes and warrant tailored support that addresses the specific nature of mind wandering. Automated detection of these episodes could help mitigate their adverse effects, for example, by developing adaptive, attention-aware learning environments. In this study (N = 87), we explored a novel multimodal approach, combining eye tracking, facial videos, and physiological wristbands (i.e., electrodermal activity and heart rate), to predict aware and unaware mind wandering during lecture video watching. In addition, to allow comparison to previous research, we also predicted an integrated mind-wandering category. Mind wandering was assessed using 15 two-stage thought probes to determine task-unrelated thoughts and the participants’ awareness of their mind wandering. Our findings indicate that a multimodal approach outperforms unimodal methods, utilizing the top 100 features from the fused data. Specifically, aware mind wandering was detected at 20% above chance (AUC-PR = 0.396), unaware mind wandering at 14% above chance (AUC-PR = 0.267), and the combined category at 40% above chance (AUC-PR = 0.637). Eye tracking and video features proved more predictive than physiological measures when used as standalone modalities. SHAP analysis, employed to explain the results, highlighted the significance of integrating features from all three modalities for effective detection, particularly emphasizing the role of video-based facial expressions in identifying unaware mind wandering. Going beyond the current state of the art, this study demonstrates the potential of leveraging multimodal data to enhance the precision of aware and unaware mind-wandering detection and differentiation, setting a foundation for advancing educational technologies that respond dynamically to learners’ cognitive states.